1 Custom build by Black Badger
Best for fabricators tracking each piece from detailing to erection
A steel job is tracked by the piece. Each member is detailed, cut, fit, welded, inspected, loaded and erected in a sequence, and the shop and the field need the same status. None of the contractor products on this list describe fabrication tracking, and BuildOps says plainly which trades it serves, with steel not among them. Black Badger publishes this guide and builds custom software. We build the piece tracker, the load list and the erection status as one system you own.
Watch for. We rank a custom build first because the products fit steel poorly. A build starts with discovery and a written scope, and there is no per-seat fee afterward.
- How it charges
- One-time build scoped in writing, then running costs such as hosting
- Main limit
- Needs a scoping call first, and suits companies of 50 or more employees
What a custom build involves, and how to ask about one
2 eSUB
Best for erection crews and project managers in the field
eSUB is the best product for the field half of a steel contractor. An erector is a commercial subcontractor with crews, daily production to record and extra work to document, and eSUB is built for exactly that buyer. The Advanced tier adds change orders, T&M tracking and progress billing. It ranks second because it covers the site, and the fabrication shop is a different kind of work.
Watch for. Drawings are an optional add-on, and steel work depends on drawings. Include that add-on and the Advanced tier in any quote you compare.
- How it charges
- Quoted by user count and modules, not by annual revenue
- Main limit
- Built for subcontractors, with drawings and integrations as optional add-ons
3 Procore
Best for large steel contractors on major commercial projects
Procore ranks third. It suits a large specialty contractor that wants one project management platform for many teams. A steel contractor on big projects deals with a heavy flow of RFIs, submittals and drawing revisions with the general contractor. No charge for added users means detailers, project managers and erection foremen can all be in it. The pages we read describe project management, so plan on the shop being tracked elsewhere.
Watch for. The fee follows annual construction volume. Steel contracts carry a lot of material value, so ask how that volume is counted for a fabricator.
- How it charges
- Annual fee by product, based on construction volume
- Main limit
- Priced on your annual construction volume, so cost rises as your work grows
4 Smartsheet
Best for shops tracking piece status in shared sheets today
Smartsheet is fourth, and some shops already use a tool like it. A sheet with one row per piece or per sequence, statuses the shop updates and a Gantt for erection is a workable tracker on a few jobs. Business plans list unlimited automations, so status changes can notify the field. It ranks here because steel contractors outgrow it. A sheet treats a piece the same as a task.
Watch for. The Pro plan stops at 10 members and marks API calls as unavailable. A fabricator of this size needs Business or Enterprise.
- How it charges
- Per member, billed yearly or monthly, Enterprise quoted
- Main limit
- Pro stops at 10 members and 250 automations a month, no API calls
5 FOUNDATION
Best for steel contractors that need shop and field payroll by job
FOUNDATION ranks fifth. A steel contractor pays shop labor and field labor differently and needs both costed to the job, and this product has Job Costing and Payroll built in. Equipment Management is an add-on, which matters to an erector that owns cranes and lifts. It ranks below the tracking tools because it answers what a job cost and not where a piece is.
Watch for. Equipment Management and Mobile Time Tracking are add-on modules, and pricing is modular with no published dollar amounts.
- How it charges
- Quoted, modular pricing with paid add-on modules
- Main limit
- Modular pricing, with Service Dispatch and Equipment Management as add-ons
6 Microsoft Project and Planner plans
Best for erectors sequencing work on Microsoft 365
Microsoft Project is sixth. Erection is a sequencing problem, and Planner and Project Plan 3 lists critical path, baselines and resource management at a published per-user price, paid yearly. For a project manager planning crane time and crew sequence it is enough. It ranks low because it plans the work and records none of it. Piece status and field production are recorded somewhere else.
Watch for. Plan 1 lists portfolios as view-only and lacks the desktop app. Give Plan 3 to the people who build schedules and no one else.
- How it charges
- Per user, paid yearly, or monthly at a higher rate
- Main limit
- Plan 1 shows portfolios view-only, full resource tools start at Plan 3
7 CMiC
Best for large steel subcontractors that want one financial database
CMiC ranks seventh. It fits subcontractors as well as general contractors, and offers accounting and project controls on a single database. A large steel contractor with several divisions may want that. It ranks last on this list because the question is about running steel work, and a construction ERP answers a different question. It would sit under a tracking system and would not replace one.
Watch for. CMiC publishes no price or deployment model. Confirm which of its listed areas a quote covers before comparing it with anything else.
- How it charges
- Quoted by sales, no published price
- Main limit
- No price or deployment model is stated on its pages, so both need a sales call